anghara (anghara) wrote,
anghara
anghara

They are not disposable.

Warning: RANT!

That movie that won the Oscar - "Slumdog Millionaire" - I haven't seen it. Haven't particularly been drawn to do so. But right now I feel as though I ought to do more than just shrug and say, eh, I probably won't go see it. I feel as though I ought to be standing in front of a cinema that's showing it and handing out copies of THIS article, and begging people to boycott the whole thing.

This... this... you don't DO this to people. Let alone childrend.

Does anybody realise what an Indian slum really is? What these kids were plucked from? The filth, the crowding, the disease, the inadequacy - indeed, the pure and simple lack - of what a Western mind would consider the most elementary sanitary facilities (running water? What's that?) - and from this, two vulnerable and (let's face it) eminently exploitable kids are whisked into... Beverly Hills. Where you use a TELEPHONE to converse with another part of the SAME BUILDING, where the waste of space is so egregious that there are entire areas of the buliding dedicated to a single purpoose (for instance, the kitchen) or for the use of a single person (indoor plumbing is fine but now you have an ENTIRE GLITZY BATHROOM which nobody is using but yourself) - you get a room that's bigger than your entire one-roomed vermin-infested shack back where you came from, and you get the whole thing for yourself and you don't have to share it with six siblings, your parents, possibly an uncle or an aunt and a grandparent or two, and half a dozen rats, and a legion of fleas and flies and centipedes and possibly poisonous spiders or centipedes. You sleep on a bed, with clean linens, and you have it all to yourself - you don't have to huddle on the floor wrapped in ragged covers which you have to fight for with the four people who are sharing the same space. You eat clean and well-cooked food and you drink clean cold water (possibly out of plastic bottles bought in a store, no less). You are then dressed up in clothes the likes of which you've never seen before and taken to the red carpet of Oscar Night.

And then you are given $2500 (apparently it's only $700 for the girl), a promise of more money when you turn 18 (and if you *stay in school*, no less), and you are taken back to the hellhole where they found you and turfed right back there. And your families no longer see you as a child but as a money-making machine, and already the boy has been beaten up by his father because he would not speak to a reporter who promised his father money.

*These are children*. They are human beings. They are not disposable or recyclable. If you could not make your movie without exploiting a human being in this manner, Mr Director, you probably should not have made it. But these particular human beings made your career skyrocket, made your name known, raised your stock in Hollywood - these particular human beings let you make a film that will line your pockets with money - and you think that giving the pair of them less than $4000 and fobbing them off with promises of more contingent on fulfilling criteria which the life that you flung them back to may not enable them to keep, you think that takes care of your responsibilities?...

I'm disgusted. I'm sick and disgusted. If you had the urge to go pay money to see "Slumdog Millionaire", perhaps you should consider spending it elsewhere. If I knew how to do it, I would be setting up a fund right now where people who would have paid $10 or $40 or whatever to go see the movie could send that money into the fund instead and the money would go directly to those poor children who were used and then dumped when their usefulness came to an end. But I haven't the knowledge or the power to do this, all I have is my outrage, and that's what I have to share.

THEY ARE NOT DISPOSABLE. You do not kick them to the curb when you're done with them. You chose them, Mr Director, and now you are responsible - no, you don't have to adopt them, but you are responsible for their future because it is partly an expectation of a future that you have created for them. At the very least that "Stay in school" criterion should be your responsibility, and that means leaving the slums. Get them a place to live so that they CAN stay in school. Make sure their families don't treat them as cash cows, dangling them in front of journalists for payouts - because the interest WILL die down eventually, and the kids will stop being cute and photogenic, and the money will dry up, and the families will take it out on the kids.

For God's sake, show some backbone. You made your choices, now live with the consequences. You don't owe them Beverly Hills, but you owe them clean beds and clean water. You owe them that. You owe them much more than $700 - that's what you would spend taking four friends out to dinner at a Beverly Hills restaurant. Do two less dinners a month and send your "stars" the money instead... at the very, very least. What you did to these children you wouldn't do to a dog, and they are not dogs. They're people. They are people to whom you gave hope. Well, Mr Director, hope isn't something you merely lend until you demand it back (and the people you lent it to had better not have damaged it). YOU started this, and if you didn't you know who did - and the people who started this now need to stay the course with it. These children are not disposable. You had no responsibility for them before you chose them to help make you rich - they were India's problem, their parents' problem, anyone else's problem but yours. But you CHOSE them. You picked them. You MADE them your problem. Now you owe them more than just a handful of AMerican dollars and a pat on the head.

Go take care of your responsibilities.

End of rant.

But... unless the right thing is done and done fast...my fervent hope is that everyone hwo gives a damn will boycott the movie.
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 14 comments