anghara (anghara) wrote,

Busy, but here's something for you to play with if you're inclined to chat...

The stuff in bold is mine, in response to another poster:

> >>>> Long-term consequences not my problem, nor anything I'd consider in
> >>>>the circumstance of "wipe 'em out or your wife and kids get it".
> >>>>
> >>>
> >>> I understand the "in-the-moment" angst of choosing mosquitoes or your
> >>> wife, but, um, long term consequences would probably conspire to make
> >>> you lose your wife anyway, to some unforeseen niggle in the
> >>> mosquitoless space time continuum.

> >>
> >> I do not accept no-win scenarios.
> >
> >That depends on your values for the word "win"
> >
> >I, on the other hand, do not accept scenarios where I am the last
> >living thing standing, waving what's left of the atomic bomb and
> >screaming "I won" to a world which is now devoid of ears to hear me.
> >
> >Winning is one thing. WInning is good. Winning makes you FEEL good.
> >But winning at any cost... makes me into the sort of person I do not
> >wish to be. I'd like to believe I'd think before I shoot - and there
> >are scenarios where, if personal sacrifice was necessary, I'd like to
> >believe that I had it in me to make it. That, too, would be "winning",
> >in one sense of the word. Anyone can survive. Few people truly "win".

The discussion, for the record, was originally about whether it would be acceptable to destroy an entire species in exchange for the safety of one's wife and child.

The question, should you choose to accept it, is this: is "winning" at any cost really winning at all?

Go nuts.

I've a chapter to finish.
Tags: philosophical discussions, writing

  • We provide... Leverage

    What suricattus and matociquala say here, cosigned: If I am a guest at a convention you are attending, or simply a fellow attendee, and…

  • A timely PSA...

    Christmas is coming and you may be thinking about what to give the readers inyour life. If you are interested in giving a signed book as a gift…

  • An anniversary approaches.

    Someone brought this to my attention today, and it is eerily appropriate to some of my own recent thoughts. Because, you see, there is an odd time…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded