So - what do you think, folks?
Poll #1189015 Book trailers
Open to: All, detailed results viewable to: All
Book trailers - waste of money or best promotional tool ever?
OOOOH, shiny. Book trailer. Where do I go to buy the book?![]()
![]()
1 (4.8%)
Interesting - where do I go to learn more about the book?![]()
![]()
1 (4.8%)
Meh - if I wanted to get the book I wouldn't need a trailer to tell me that.![]()
![]()
14 (66.7%)
Depends on the book - some work better than others![]()
![]()
4 (19.0%)
Get thee behind me Satan - they are horrible and I would never buy a book advertised by one!![]()
![]()
1 (4.8%)
Should I do one?
OOOOH, shiny - love to see it!![]()
![]()
3 (15.8%)
Interesting - it would make me consider biying the book.![]()
![]()
0 (0.0%)
Just put over there with the rest of 'em, I'll look at it if I get around to it![]()
![]()
15 (78.9%)
Do one, and I"ll never buy any of your books again...![]()
![]()
1 (5.3%)
If you answered yes (to any degree) above -
Do a short one for "Spellspam" now, and a proper one for "Cybermage" later![]()
![]()
2 (15.4%)
Do a short one for "Spellspam" now and a proper one for the whole trilogy later![]()
![]()
1 (7.7%)
Don't bother doing a "Spellspam" one, just do a proper one for the whole trilogy when "Cybermage" isdue out![]()
![]()
5 (38.5%)
Don't do it at all! What were you thinking? Where did you see me saying yes?![]()
![]()
5 (38.5%)
I have to start thinking about the logistics of this, if the feeling is positive towards having one. Do any of y'all know someone who is in the business of producing these whom you can recommend...?


Comments
Would it be shown in movie theaters as one of the ads before a film? While most people who read books do at least see the occasional film (I go out about once a year to the movies), I don't think the reverse is true. And people tend to ignore the stuff before the main feature.
I guess it depends on the content/style as well. If it features characters from your book, I would come down heavily with a no. I'm one of those people who, once they've seen the film of a book, am forever ruined by seeing the actors. I could never read THE WIZARD OF OZ as a child because I'd seen Judy Garland as Dorothy. I don't believe she was Baum's Dorothy. Elijah Wood is beautiful and very emo, but he's not what Frodo looks like. Fortunately, I had read the book enough times that it's not a spoiler for me that it would be if it were my first introduction. (Also, I think the actress who plays Eowyn is adorable, but this bright, sunny creature is not the ice maiden of Rohan that I picture when I read the book. The real Eowyn looks more like the woman who played Talia, the blonde telepath on Babylon 5.)
I'd rather read the back flap and see excerpts. It doesn't hurt to have people talking about the book too. I have bought books I would never have picked up because other people have talked about them, and enjoyed them.
Look around in your area for wedding videographers. Watch their videos, especially their titles! If you find yourself liking what they do, drop them a line. Many of them have "side-work" and might be interested in taking an afternoon or two to film your book's artwork. Directing it yourself, hiring friends as "actors" -- it could be fun.
This tack works better in places where weddings are cheaper, obviously, not in major metros.
Good luck!
Other than
And if you have to venture into video, my gut feeling is that a short film with great music that tells a story in itself would work better than just 'this is what the book is about' in moving pictures.
i love reading excerpts.
I'd say, only do it if you're sure you can get one done really, really well, or if you have fun with it and put it on your website, not so much expecting it to be a promotional thing, but something to amuse your visitors.
And it's the 'done well' that is the hard and expensive part! My advice would be to narrow the scope to one or two ideas - and make sure they're really good hooks, either for the book or the series - and spend heaps of time on the script. Max of 30 secs, keep the download small, and invest in a professional.
As for a recommendation of who to do? Nadine does all of the trailers for Random House and she's good: http://www.nadinegoss.com.au/. Have a look at the Ranger's Apprentice trailer or trawl around on http://www.randomhouse.com.au/Default.a
The Joffre Street Productions guys are very very smart, and I have a lot of respect for them. Not as much industry experience - in terms of books - but they'd do a good job with the right script: http://www.joffrestreetproductions.com/
Good luck! Email me - fmclennan AT randomhouse DOT com DOT au - if you want more advice... I have some tips and tricks about book trailers from a presentation lying around somewhere that I could load to slideshare if that would be useful.